
In our introduction to mitigated speech, we explored how the way we communicate – and sometimes what we leave unsaid – can influence decisions in the mountains.
We looked at how differences in experience, confidence and perceived authority can affect group dynamics, and why people sometimes soften their concerns or stay quiet rather than challenge a suggestion.
But understanding why it happens is one thing. Doing something about it is another.
So how do you recognise when you’re not saying what you really think? And how do you find the confidence to speak up, particularly when you’re riding with people who are more experienced, more confident or simply more vocal than you?
Mitigated speech isn’t always obvious. Sometimes it’s a conscious decision to soften what we’re saying. Sometimes it’s a question instead of a statement, an apology before raising a concern or a suggestion that we know is unlikely to be followed up.
And sometimes we simply say nothing.
Recognising these behaviours is the first step towards changing them.
Think about whether you’ve ever:
These are all very human responses. Nobody wants to be the person who causes friction, slows the group down or appears to lack confidence.
But recognising these behaviours is the first step towards changing them.
One of the biggest barriers to speaking up is the assumption that someone else knows better.
Perhaps you’re riding with someone who has spent years exploring the mountains, completed more training or regularly tackles terrain that you wouldn’t normally consider.
It’s easy to assume that their judgement must be better than yours.
This is closely connected to the Expert Halo, one of the heuristic traps we describe here.
The problem isn’t that experienced Riders have knowledge worth listening to. They absolutely do. It’s that we can sometimes give their opinions more weight than they deserve, simply because of who they are.
Remember:
And importantly, you don’t need to be able to explain something technically to have a valid concern.
You might not know why a particular route makes you uncomfortable. You might simply feel that it’s beyond your ability or that the consequences of getting something wrong are more than you’re prepared to accept.
That’s enough.
The aim isn’t to become confrontational or turn every discussion into an argument. It’s to make sure what you’re thinking and feeling is communicated clearly enough for others to understand.
There’s a difference between being confrontational and being clear.
A few simple habits can help.
If you’re uncomfortable with a proposed route, say so.
You don’t need to dress up a serious concern as a minor reservation or tentative suggestion.
Instead of:
“I’m not particularly sure I’m up for that.”
Try:
“I’m not comfortable with that route. I’d rather find another option.”
Or:
“I don’t think that’s within my ability today.”
There’s a difference between being confrontational and being clear. You can be respectful and open to discussion without diluting what you’re trying to communicate.
A concern is easier to explore when it’s linked to something specific.
Perhaps the terrain looks more challenging than expected. Maybe you’re unfamiliar with the area, the visibility has deteriorated or you’re simply not feeling as confident as you did earlier.
You don’t need to have all the answers.
Sharing an observation or asking a question can be enough to start a useful conversation.
For example:
“I’m not familiar with this area. Can we take a moment to look at the route before we commit?”
Or:
“I’m finding the conditions more difficult than I expected. Can we reconsider the plan?”
And remember, not every concern needs a technical explanation. If you’re uncomfortable with something, that’s worth taking seriously in its own right. You read more about this here.
It’s much easier to contribute when everyone is given the opportunity to share their thoughts before a decision is made. Once someone more experienced or confident has expressed a strong opinion, it can become harder to offer a different perspective. You might find yourself questioning whether your concern is valid, or simply going along with a decision because it feels as though the group has already agreed.
If you’re part of a group discussion, try to share your thoughts early, before the conversation becomes settled. And if you’re waiting for an opportunity to contribute, remember that you don’t need to have the perfect words or a fully formed argument. A question, an observation or simply saying that something doesn’t feel right is enough to start a conversation.
Good group decisions shouldn’t depend on who speaks first or loudest. Everyone should have the opportunity to contribute before the group settles on a plan.
One of the biggest mistakes is leaving it until everyone is standing at the entrance to a line before expressing reservations.
By then, the group may already have invested time and effort in getting there. Everyone might have their equipment ready, and the expectation to continue can feel difficult to resist.
But decisions happen throughout the day.
You can question the plan before leaving the resort, suggest a different area, raise concerns during the approach or change your mind when you see the terrain for yourself.
The earlier a concern is raised, the more opportunity the group has to explore alternatives.
Our Group Safety Checklist encourages Riders to plan together before heading out and keep communicating as the day develops. Make use of those opportunities rather than waiting for a problem to arise.
Speaking up isn’t about winning an argument.
You might raise a concern, discuss it with the group and come to a different conclusion. Equally, someone else might highlight something you hadn’t considered.
The aim is to make the best possible decision with the information available, not to defend an initial opinion or prove who knows the most.
But don’t confuse being open to discussion with feeling obliged to agree.
You can listen to other people’s views and still decide that something isn’t right for you.
Sometimes a discussion will resolve a concern. Sometimes it won’t.
If you’re still uncomfortable after talking it through, you don’t have to commit.
You can simply say:
“I’m not comfortable with this. I’m not going to ride it.”
It may feel awkward the first time you make this call but it’s actually something for you and the group to celebrate. It’s the sign of a crew who respect each other and collaborate effectively.That’s not a failure, and it shouldn’t require an elaborate explanation or an apology.
There will always be other lines, other slopes and other days. No single descent is worth feeling pressured into taking a risk you’re not prepared to accept.
There’s another important point worth remembering: just because nobody else has raised a concern doesn’t mean you’re the only person who has one.
A group where people feel able to disagree is much better placed to make informed decisions than one where everyone simply follows along.
Other people might be feeling exactly the same way.
Perhaps they’re waiting for someone else to say something, or they’re worried about being the first to question the plan.
By speaking up, you might give someone else the confidence to do the same.
And if someone else does raise a concern, support them. Don’t dismiss it, make a joke at their expense or automatically defer to the most experienced person in the group.
A group where people feel able to disagree is much better placed to make informed decisions than one where everyone simply follows along.
The best groups crowdsource their safety when they move beyond the markers or the resort boundary.
Being part of a group means looking beyond your own experience. Are the people you’re riding with enjoying themselves? Is someone finding the terrain more challenging than expected? And what about the person leading – are they having a good day too?
It’s easy to assume that the person who knows the area best or has the most experience is happy to take responsibility for everything. But they might be managing the plan, keeping an eye on the group and making decisions throughout the day, leaving little time to enjoy the riding themselves.
Think about how you can help. Share your observations, offer to take the lead on a section if you’re comfortable doing so, help with navigation or simply check in with the person who’s been looking after everyone else.
A good group looks out for one another. That means sharing more than just the descent – it’s about sharing the decisions, the responsibility and the enjoyment too.
Speaking up becomes easier when it’s part of how you ride, rather than something you only do when you’re particularly worried.
Get into the habit of contributing to discussions before heading out, sharing observations as the day develops and asking questions when something isn’t clear.
Our Group Safety Checklist provides a useful starting point. It encourages everyone to collaborate on the day’s plan, check that the group is happy and build decision points into the route at regular intervals or pause to reassess when circumstances change.
Use those moments to contribute, rather than simply waiting for someone else to lead the conversation.
And if you find yourself regularly holding back, think about why. Is it the people you’re riding with? Is it a lack of confidence? Or are you worried about how your contribution will be received?
These are worth reflecting on. The group we ride with should make us feel more confident about sharing our thoughts, not less. If you don’t feel welcome, heard or you’re not enjoying their company, then either something fundamental needs to change or maybe it’s just not the group for you.
Nothing beats riding with a crew that lets you be yourself and appreciates your opinions. At the end of the day FreeRiding is always better shared with buddies.
At FreeRide Republic, we believe that sharing knowledge and learning from one another are fundamental to being a better FreeRider – see Lore #07.
The person who decides not to ride a line might be making the most important contribution of the day
That means recognising that everyone has something to contribute, regardless of experience or technical ability.
The person who spots something everyone else has missed might not be the most experienced Rider in the group. The person who asks an awkward question might prevent a poor decision. And the person who decides not to ride a line might be making the most important contribution of the day.
You don’t need to be an expert to have an opinion. You don’t need to justify being uncomfortable. And you certainly don’t need to follow someone else simply because they appear more confident.
Respect experience, listen to others and be prepared to learn, but don’t forget your judgement is also important.
Part 1: Understanding Mitigated Speech in the Mountains — Speak Up, Stay Safe
Understand why we sometimes soften what we say or stay silent, and how this can influence decisions in the mountains.
Part 3: Understanding Mitigated Speech in the Mountains — Leading Together
If you’re the more experienced Rider, the person who usually takes the lead or simply someone who wants to help create a better group dynamic, discover how to make open communication part of the way you ride together.
Mitigated Speech and Communication
Linde, C. (1988). The Quantitative Study of Communicative Success: Politeness and Accidents in Aviation Discourse. Language in Society, 17(3), 375–399.
Explores how the way we communicate can influence whether concerns are understood and acted upon, particularly when speaking to people with greater authority.
Group Formation and Decision-Making in Avalanche Terrain
Zweifel, B. & Haegeli, P. (2014). A Qualitative Analysis of Group Formation, Leadership and Decision Making in Recreation Groups Traveling in Avalanche Terrain. Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism, 5–6, 17–26.
Explores how group formation, leadership and decision-making influence safety among recreational groups travelling in avalanche terrain.
The takeaway: You don’t have to be the most experienced person in the group to have something valuable to say. Speak clearly, listen to others and never feel obliged to ride something you’re uncomfortable with.
Explore the themes below to find the best home for the content you want to learn about: