
Why good leadership isn’t about having all the answers – it’s about creating the conditions for everyone to contribute.
In our articles about mitigated speech and finding your voice, we’ve explored why people sometimes soften their concerns or stay quiet when riding with others, and how individuals can develop the confidence to speak up.
But communication isn’t just an individual responsibility.
If you’re the person others look to for advice, the one who knows the area best or the Rider who usually takes the lead, you have an important influence over how the group behaves.
Your experience and confidence can be reassuring, but they can also make it harder for others to question you.
So how do you create an environment where everyone feels able to contribute, challenge assumptions and raise concerns without worrying about how they’ll be received?
Experience is valuable. Time spent observing conditions, assessing terrain and making decisions builds knowledge that can’t simply be acquired from reading a guidebook.
But experience doesn’t make anyone infallible.
And the more influence you have the greater your responsibility to encourage others to have their say.
This is particularly important because of something known as the Expert Halo.
The Expert Halo is one of the heuristic traps identified by avalanche researcher Ian McCammon. It describes the tendency to place excessive trust in someone because they appear to have greater experience or expertise.
When this happens, other group members may stop questioning decisions, defer to the perceived expert or assume that someone else has already considered the important factors.
The danger isn’t necessarily that the most experienced person makes a poor decision. It’s that the group loses access to information and perspectives that might have helped everyone make a better one.
You can find out more about this and the other heuristic traps in our Heuristic Traps article.
In organisational psychology, the term psychological safety is used to describe an environment where people feel able to ask questions, admit uncertainty, share ideas and raise concerns without fear of negative consequences.
“People are much more likely to contribute when they know their opinions will be taken seriously.”
It’s a useful concept for thinking about group dynamics in the mountains.
People are much more likely to contribute when they know their opinions will be taken seriously.
As a group leader or more experienced Rider, there are several simple things you can do to encourage this.
One of the simplest ways to do this is to ask open, inclusive questions. Rather than asking for confirmation that everyone is happy with a decision, encourage people to share what they’re thinking, what they’ve noticed and whether anything is giving them pause.
It might seem like a small change, but the way we ask questions can make a real difference to the answers we get. We’re not just giving people permission to speak; we’re actively inviting them into the conversation.
Don’t assume that everyone will volunteer their thoughts.
Some people are naturally more vocal than others. Others might need a little encouragement, particularly if they’re less experienced or unfamiliar with the group.
Instead of simply asking whether everyone is happy with the plan, invite people to share what they’ve noticed or whether they have any concerns.
Think about the difference between asking “Everyone happy with the plan?” and “How is everyone feeling about the plan?”
The first invites a simple yes or no. The second encourages people to explain their thinking, raise questions or express uncertainty. It makes a response more than just agreement or disagreement.
Try questions such as:
Make sure everyone has an opportunity to contribute, not just the people who are most confident or experienced.
If you’re suggesting a particular route or making a decision about where to go, explain why.
Give others the opportunity to share their thoughts before explaining your own. Once everyone has had a chance to contribute, talk through what you’ve considered, why you’ve reached your current view, where you’re uncertain and what might change your mind.
Being open about your thinking helps others understand the reasoning behind a decision, while showing that your own view isn’t fixed or beyond question. It also reinforces that everyone in the group is there to contribute, and that the plan can evolve as new information or perspectives emerge.
Simply announcing that something is fine because you’ve done it before doesn’t help anyone else understand the reasoning.
It can also reinforce the Expert Halo, encouraging others to accept your judgement without questioning it.
Sharing your thinking makes the decision-making process more transparent and gives everyone something they can contribute to, as well as leading to better outcomes.
How you respond when someone raises a concern can make a significant difference to whether they do it again.
“You don’t have to agree with every concern, but you should make sure it’s properly heard.”
Avoid immediately dismissing questions or responding with comments such as:
“I’ve done this loads of times.”
“It’ll be fine.”
“Don’t worry about it.”
Even if you genuinely believe the plan is sound, these responses can make someone feel that their concerns aren’t welcome.
Instead, take a moment to understand what they’re saying.
Ask why they’re uncomfortable, explore what they’ve noticed and consider whether there’s something you haven’t thought about.
You don’t have to agree with every concern, but you should make sure it’s properly heard.
Sometimes people might struggle to explain exactly what’s bothering them. Rather than immediately looking for a reason to dismiss their concern, give them the space to talk it through. Acknowledge what they’ve noticed and show that you’re taking it seriously.
You might say:
You don’t need to have an immediate answer. Sometimes giving someone the space to work through their thoughts is enough to bring an important observation into the conversation.
Research into aviation safety communication highlights an important point: speaking up is only effective if the people receiving the message listen and respond appropriately.
You don’t have to know everything.
In fact, being prepared to admit uncertainty can be one of the most useful things you do as a leader.
“Changing the plan isn’t a failure of leadership. Sometimes it’s the best decision you can make.”
Uncertainty comes with the territory when FreeRiding. There are no guarantees in the mountains, and experience doesn’t make anyone immune to getting things wrong. Even the most experienced Riders can misjudge a situation, overlook something or find themselves facing conditions they didn’t expect.
If you’re unsure about something, say so. If you need more information, take the time to find it. If someone else knows more about a particular aspect of the situation, make space for them to share that knowledge.
This helps establish that nobody is expected to have all the answers. Recognising uncertainty, asking questions and learning from one another are all part of making better decisions as a group.
It’s easy to become attached to an idea, particularly when you’ve spent time planning a particular route or getting everyone excited about a proposed line.
But the plan should always remain open to change.
If someone raises a valid concern, take it seriously. If conditions have changed, reassess. If the group isn’t comfortable with the proposed route, consider alternatives.
Changing the plan isn’t a failure of leadership. Sometimes it’s the best decision you can make. You can read more about that in the F.A.C.E.T.S. section of this article.
One of the biggest mistakes groups can make is leaving important conversations until they’re standing at the entrance to a line.
By then, people might feel committed. They’ve travelled to the area, made the approach and invested time and effort in getting there.
The pressure to continue can become much greater.
But good group decision-making should start much earlier.
Think about the different stages of a day in the mountains:
Before heading out
Who are we riding with? What are everyone’s experience, ability and expectations? What are we hoping to achieve? Is the proposed objective appropriate for the group?
Choosing where to go
Have we discussed the options? Does everyone understand the plan? Have we considered alternatives and the conditions that might influence our choices?
On the move
Are things as expected? Has anything changed? Is everyone comfortable with the direction we’re heading? Do we need to pause and reassess?
Before committing to more consequential terrain
Has everyone had an opportunity to share their observations and concerns? Does everyone understand the plan and the potential consequences? Is anyone holding back?
These aren’t simply boxes to tick. They’re opportunities for ongoing communication.
A decision point that made sense an hour ago might not make sense now.
And everyone should feel able to question it at any stage.
At FreeRide Republic, we’ve already put together a practical Group Safety Checklist to help Riders remember the important checks before heading out, at the meeting point, while on the move and when returning home.
It encourages groups to collaborate on their plan, ensure everyone knows what’s happening, remind themselves of heuristic traps and keep communicating throughout the day.
It’s a useful starting point, but it’s important that the checklist becomes a genuine conversation rather than a box-ticking exercise.
As the person leading the group, you can help make that happen.
A few simple habits are particularly useful:
Most importantly, don’t use the checklist to obtain agreement for a decision that’s already been made.
Use it to help the group make a better-informed decision together.
There’s one more thing worth remembering: FreeRiding should be fun.
If you’re the person who usually takes the lead, knows the area best or has the most experience, it’s easy to find yourself taking responsibility for the whole group.
You’re choosing the routes, assessing the conditions, keeping an eye on everyone, answering questions and making sure the day goes to plan.
That can be rewarding, but it can also become quite a responsibility. Particularly if you start to feel that everyone else’s enjoyment, decisions and safety rest on your shoulders.
It’s worth recognising when this is happening. Are you still enjoying the day, or are you spending most of your time worrying about everyone else? Do you feel you have to make every decision, or that you can’t relax because you’re responsible for what happens next?
If so, it might be time to share the load.
A few simple things can help:
Taking the lead doesn’t mean having to take charge of everything. And being the most experienced person in the group doesn’t mean you have to carry all the responsibility.
The best groups share more than just the descent. They share the planning, the decision-making, the responsibility and, of course, the enjoyment.
After all, we’re here because we love riding mountains. Let’s make sure we don’t lose sight of that.
Sometimes, despite your best efforts, the group dynamic simply isn’t conducive to good decision-making.
Perhaps one person dominates every conversation. Maybe concerns are repeatedly dismissed, or people are expected to follow the most experienced Rider without question.
These are warning signs.
If people don’t feel able to contribute, the group isn’t making the most of the knowledge and experience available to it.
And if important concerns aren’t being heard, it’s time to stop and reconsider how you’re operating.
Good leadership isn’t about maintaining control or getting everyone to agree with you. It’s about recognising when the group needs to change direction, whether that’s choosing another route, changing the plan or deciding that the conditions aren’t right for the day’s objective.
Sometimes, the best thing a group can do is walk away.
At FreeRide Republic, we believe that good FreeRiding is about more than finding great lines. It’s about learning, sharing knowledge, understanding the risks and looking out for the people we ride with.
“Better decisions don’t come from one person having all the answers. They come from making the best use of the knowledge, experience and observations of everyone in the group.”
That means creating an environment where everyone feels able to contribute, regardless of experience or ability.
If you’re the person others look to for guidance, remember that your influence comes with responsibility.
Invite questions. Share your thinking. Listen carefully. Be open about uncertainty. And be prepared to change the plan.
The strongest groups aren’t necessarily those where everyone follows the most experienced Rider. They’re the ones where everyone feels able to think, question, contribute and, when necessary, disagree – they crowdsource their intel.
Because better decisions don’t come from one person having all the answers. They come from making the best use of the knowledge, experience and observations of everyone in the group.
Part 1: Understanding Mitigated Speech in the Mountains — Speak Up, Stay Safe. Discover why we sometimes soften what we say or stay silent, and how this can influence decisions in the mountains.
Part 2: Understanding Mitigated Speech in the Mountains — Finding Your Voice. Explore how to recognise when you’re holding back, overcome the pressure to agree and communicate your concerns more confidently.
Psychological Safety and Team Communication
Nembhard, I. M. & Edmondson, A. C. (2012). Psychological Safety: A Foundation for Speaking Up, Collaboration, and Experimentation in Organizations. In The Oxford Handbook of Positive Organizational Scholarship, 491–504.
Explores how creating an environment where people feel comfortable asking questions, admitting uncertainty and challenging assumptions encourages better communication and collaboration.
Speaking Up – and Being Heard
Noort, M. C., Reader, T. W. & Gillespie, A. (2021). Safety Voice and Safety Listening During Aviation Accidents: Cockpit Voice Recordings Reveal That Speaking-Up to Power Is Not Enough. Safety Science, 139, 105260.
Highlights why speaking up about safety concerns is only part of the equation. Those in positions of influence also need to listen, acknowledge and act on what they’re being told.
Collective Decision-Making and Avalanche Risk
Ebert, P. A. & Morreau, M. (2022). Safety in Numbers: How Social Choice Theory Can Inform Avalanche Risk Management. Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 23(3), 340–356.
Examines when groups can make better decisions by combining individual knowledge and perspectives – and when group dynamics can instead undermine collective judgement.
The takeaway: Good leadership isn’t about being the person who makes all the decisions. It’s about creating a group where everyone can contribute to making better ones.
Explore the themes below to find the best home for the content you want to learn about: