
Good decisions in the mountains depend on more than knowledge, experience and the right equipment. They also depend on our ability to communicate openly, question assumptions and listen to one another.
We all want to make good decisions in the mountains. We check the avalanche bulletin, assess the conditions, consider the terrain and make a plan with our riding companions. We invest in the right equipment and, hopefully, take the time to learn how to use it and practice regularly.
“The words we choose, the concerns we leave unspoken and the way we respond to other people’s questions can all influence the decisions we make together.”
But there’s another part of mountain safety that can be harder to recognise: how we communicate with one another.Are we comfortable questioning the plan? Will we say something if we’re uncertain about a line, uncomfortable with the terrain or worried about a change in conditions? And, just as importantly, will the rest of the group listen?It might seem like a small thing. But the words we choose, the concerns we leave unspoken and the way we respond to other people’s questions can all influence the decisions we make together.One concept that helps us understand this is mitigated speech.
In our article Research, Risk and the Reality of Avalanche Terrain, we explored research into how riders perceive avalanche risk in the European Alps, and the uncomfortable gap that can exist between what we know and how we behave when faced with real terrain, social dynamics and changing conditions.
One of the challenges is that avalanche terrain is what researchers describe as a wicked learning environment. Poor decisions are not always immediately punished. We can make the wrong call many times without consequence. Familiarity, previous success and the absence of visible avalanche activity can all create a false sense of security and reinforce complacency.
As the saying goes: nothing happens… most of the time.
The research also raised an important point about collective responsibility. Carrying a transceiver, shovel and probe does not automatically make us rescue-ready. Equipment ownership is not the same as the ability to respond effectively as a group. That takes practice, shared understanding and a willingness to take responsibility for one another.
There is another part of this picture worth considering.
What happens when someone in the group has a concern, a doubt or a different opinion, but doesn’t feel comfortable expressing it?
Perhaps they’re less experienced than the others. Perhaps someone in the group is regarded as the expert. Perhaps everyone seems happy with the plan, and they don’t want to be the one who holds things up.
The result can be that important information never makes it into the conversation. A rider’s uncertainty, discomfort or observation is lost, not necessarily because they lack the knowledge to recognise a problem, but because they don’t feel able to speak openly.
This is where the way we communicate becomes part of the risk-management picture. It’s not enough to have the knowledge, make a plan or carry the right equipment. We also need an environment where people can question decisions, share concerns and influence what happens next.
Mitigated speech is a term used to describe the way people soften, qualify or dilute what they say, particularly when speaking to someone they perceive as more senior, experienced or authoritative.
“The problem arises when we soften a message so much that its meaning becomes unclear, or when we don’t communicate it at all.”
Instead of saying:
“I don’t feel we should be dropping here”
We might say:
“I’m not sure about this. What do you think?”
Or:
“Perhaps we should have another look at this?”
There’s nothing inherently wrong with being polite, diplomatic or open to other opinions. In fact, those are useful qualities in any group.
The problem arises when we soften a message so much that its meaning becomes unclear, or when we don’t communicate it at all.
A concern that sounds like a passing suggestion can easily be interpreted as just that. A question can be mistaken for casual conversation. And a hesitation can go unnoticed altogether.
In everyday life, this might not matter very much. In the mountains, where decisions can have serious consequences, it matters a great deal.
The concept has been studied in aviation, where researchers examined how communication between crew members and those in positions of authority can affect safety. Charlotte Linde’s research into aviation discourse found that suggestions made in a more mitigated, indirect way were more likely to be missed or misunderstood when directed up the chain of command.
The lesson isn’t that every conversation in a riding group should sound like an emergency briefing. It’s that the clarity of a message matters, particularly when someone is trying to raise a concern.
FreeRiding groups are rarely made up of people with exactly the same experience, confidence or knowledge.
There may be someone who knows the area inside out, someone with years of backcountry experience, someone who has completed formal avalanche training, and someone who is still finding their feet.
That mix can be a real strength. We learn from one another, share knowledge and benefit from different perspectives.
But experience can also create an imbalance in the way decisions are made.
If one person is seen as the expert, the rest of the group may become less inclined to question their judgement. They might assume that the more experienced rider has considered everything, or that their own concerns are probably misplaced.
This is closely related to a recognised heuristic trap known as the Expert Halo.
The Expert Halo describes our tendency to give extra weight to the opinions of someone we perceive as knowledgeable or experienced. We may defer to their judgement without properly considering the information ourselves.
It doesn’t mean that experienced riders are necessarily making poor decisions. It means that experience should not make anyone immune to questions, and it should never remove the responsibility of everyone else to think for themselves.
Our Heuristic Traps article explores this and other influences on decision-making in more detail.
Mitigated speech isn’t just relevant when we’re discussing avalanche conditions or choosing a consequential line.
It can appear much earlier in the day, and in situations that might seem relatively ordinary.
Imagine a group is discussing a route, and one rider isn’t convinced it’s right for them. Rather than say so, they make a vague comment about checking another option.
Or perhaps someone is feeling tired and would rather call it a day. They know the rest of the group is keen for another lap, so they suggest they’re “probably okay for one more”.
Maybe a group heading towards a line that one rider hasn’t skied before. They’re not sure about the steepness, but everyone else seems keen. They don’t want to hold up the group, so they say nothing.
These are all moments when a group can miss an opportunity to make a better decision.
The point isn’t that every uncertainty means we should stop or abandon the plan. It’s that everyone should be able to express how they’re feeling, what they’re seeing and what they’re comfortable with.
A blue run can be the wrong choice for someone who isn’t ready for it. A familiar route can still present unfamiliar conditions. And a rider who doesn’t want to follow a particular plan, line or person shouldn’t have to invent an excuse.
You don’t need to be an avalanche expert to know when something doesn’t feel right for you.
It’s tempting to think that the solution is simply to encourage people to speak up. But that’s only part of it.
A group can invite questions and still fail to listen. Someone can raise a concern, only to have it directly or inadvertently brushed aside, laughed off or met with an impatient response.
“A good group doesn’t just make space for people to speak. It makes space for what they say to influence the conversation.”
Research into safety communication has highlighted the importance of both speaking up and listening. In other words, creating the opportunity for someone to raise a concern is not enough if the group doesn’t take that concern seriously.
This is particularly important when there are differences in experience or confidence. The person who appears most knowledgeable may not have all the information. The quietest person in the group may have spotted something important. And the fact that nobody has objected doesn’t necessarily mean everybody agrees.
A good group doesn’t just make space for people to speak. It makes space for what they say to influence the conversation. The best groups crowdsource their safety when they move beyond the markers or the resort boundary.
The good news is that communication is something we can practise.
It starts with recognising that group decisions are not the responsibility of one person alone. Everyone has a part to play, whether they’re leading the day, navigating unfamiliar terrain or simply joining the group for a few laps.
It also means being aware of the moments when we might hold back, and recognising when our own experience or enthusiasm might make it harder for someone else to contribute.
At FreeRide Republic, our Group Safety Checklist already encourages riders to collaborate on a plan, check in with one another and pause to reassess as conditions change. These conversations shouldn’t be reserved for the moment before dropping into a line. They start before we leave the lift station and continue throughout the day.
A useful question to ask is not simply “Is everyone happy?”, but “Does anyone have a concern they haven’t raised?”
And when someone does speak up, give them the space to explain. Listen before responding. Don’t assume that a different opinion is a challenge to your experience or authority.
Understanding mitigated speech is a first step towards recognising how easily important messages can be lost. The next is learning what we can do about it.
In the next two articles in this series, we’ll look at the subject from both sides of the conversation:
Part 2: Understanding Mitigated Speech in the Mountains — Finding Your Voice
Practical ways to recognise when we’re holding back, express concerns clearly and feel more confident contributing to group decisions.
Part 3: Understanding Mitigated Speech in the Mountains — Leading Together
How those with more experience, or who take the lead, can create the conditions for open communication and better shared decisions.
Because understanding risk is one thing. Being able to talk about it openly, challenge assumptions and change our minds together is another.
A good group doesn’t just have a plan. It creates the space for everyone to question that plan, contribute to it and change it when necessary.
The aviation research cited here offers useful insights into communication, authority and listening in safety-critical environments. It is not a direct study of FreeRiding groups, but the human factors it explores are relevant to how we communicate and make decisions together in the mountains.
This article was inspired, in part, by Malcolm Gladwell’s Revisionist History podcast, and particularly the two-part series “Memorial Day, 2020”, which examines the events surrounding George Floyd’s murder.
In Part 2, Gladwell explores why a fellow police officer, who recognised what was happening and tried to intervene, did not do more. It raises difficult questions about the pressures that shape our behaviour in a group: the influence of authority, the hesitation to challenge someone, and the consequences of not speaking up when it matters.
Although the circumstances are very different, the questions resonated with us in the context of FreeRiding. How do group dynamics affect our willingness to voice a concern? What makes it difficult to challenge a decision, particularly when someone more experienced or influential is leading the way? And what can we do to make it easier for people to speak up?
We’d like to acknowledge Malcolm Gladwell and the Revisionist History team for prompting us to explore these questions.
Explore the themes below to find the best home for the content you want to learn about: